How Bishop Hotel Key West grew revenue 51% with hands-off pricing

Bishop Hotel Key West wanted automated pricing without adding back-end complexity, and worried that selling through Expedia rather than Booking.com would skew the data. Year to date, occupancy is down 5% but room revenue is up 51%.

About Bishop Hotel Key West

+51%: room revenue year to date in 2026 vs the same period of 2025

−5%: occupancy over the same period, with revenue still well ahead

December 2025: live on Pricepoint, connected to ResNexus

‍

At a glance

Company: Bishop Hotel Key West — an independent boutique hotel in Key West, Florida

Challenge: Automating pricing in an event-driven island market without adding back-end complexity, and with a channel mix built on Expedia rather than Booking.com

Solution: Pricepoint automated pricing, connected directly to the hotel's PMS, with event uplifts and room-type rules set together with the general manager

PMS: ResNexus

On Pricepoint since: December 2025

‍

No extra hands in the pot

Anthony Sibilly-Juarez, the hotel's general manager, has worked at the Bishop since it opened in 2025, and he is careful about what the hotel takes on. "At The Bishop, seamless PMS integration is essential," he says. "We avoid anything that adds back-end complexity, creates operational headaches or involves 'too many hands in the pot.'"

So the idea of handing pricing to an automated system cut both ways. "We were impressed, yet nervous with the possibility of an automated, (I would say) 95% hands-off pricing approach," he says, "but it immediately caught our attention."

‍

Two reasons to be nervous

The first was control. Key West doesn't have one high season; it has a calendar of moments. New Year's, Fantasy Fest and a string of festivals bring guests in waves, while other weeks fill late, or not at all. Letting software set those rates was a leap.

"Naturally, rolling out the trial made me nervous. Giving up manual rate control felt risky, and I worried prices might surge too high and deter bookings."

The second was data. The Bishop sells through Expedia rather than Booking.com, and Anthony had been told early on that Pricepoint's algorithm relied heavily on Booking.com. "I worried the algorithm might be skewed and our market feed would not be comprehensive without that data," he says.

‍

Building the setup together

Onboarding took two sessions in December 2025. Anthony shared two years of reports covering ADR, occupancy, discounts and booking sources, along with competitor rates for 2026 and the minimum prices he wanted for each month, based on rates the property had used as a floor for a decade. He also wanted the hotel's economy rooms, priced for more price-sensitive guests, to stay the most affordable option during busy periods.

Pricepoint's team used that to set minimum, maximum and starting prices for each room type, and to build higher prices for the island's special dates.

Another original concern that Pricepoint easily addressed was the building itself. Because the hotel is spread across historic properties, it is more like a private guesthouse than a traditional hotel, and no two rooms share the exact same layout. So every room is priced individually rather than grouped into standard rate blocks, with each rate tailored to that room's size, location, amenities and unique features, such as a balcony or poolside access.

Keeping the back end simple mattered on launch day too. ResNexus had its own occupancy-based yield rules switched on, which would have fought with Pricepoint's prices. They were turned off, leaving Pricepoint as the hotel's only pricing engine. The hotel went live on 15 December 2025.

‍

Results

The surge Anthony feared never came.

"Our ADR increased almost immediately, dynamic rate adjustments responded naturally to traveler demand without causing sticker shock, and booking volume remained steady within our target guardrails."

After the trial, the Bishop signed on in January 2026. Year to date, occupancy is 5% below last year, yet room revenue is 51% higher. "Even in areas where our occupancy may be down a few percent, revenue tends to remain higher because the system adjusted for a higher spending client," Anthony says.

"The system truly does acclimate to client demands."

Without Booking.com in the mix, the market feed held up too. "Those concerns completely dissolved," he says.

‍

Hands-off, with confidence

Anthony still keeps an eye on performance, but he no longer needs to.

"The hands-off reliability is unmatched: while I still monitor performance, I have complete confidence that I could step away for the entire year without logging in and our revenue strategy would remain optimized."

For a hotel he has known for more than a decade, he puts it simply:

"It was probably the biggest game changer we have made for our hotel in the 11 years I have worked at the property."

‍